Order of the Unseen Reading Order [Plus 7 Must-Read Recs]

Bloodshed

We like to believe monsters don’t exist, even in the moonlit streets of a place like Salem, Massachusetts. But they’re very real… and very human. There’s danger lurking around every corner. People are vanishing off the street into thin air, never to be seen again.

The masked men have their own secrets. But it isn’t until the night that they all come together when true horror is born.

College student Quinn did not expect her Halloween night to take a dangerous turn. When her masked men swoop in and make her a proposition, she can only promise one night.

Melt for Us

After going to a cabin in the woods, Quinn finds herself stuck in the midst of a blizzard with her three masked men. As they spend the holidays with one another, Quinn is left captivated.

Christmas and New Year’s Eve will never be the same.

Tis the season for giving, and receiving.

Holy, not so silent, night…

The Best of 2023: BWBH Edition

Fans of Order of the Unseen will enjoy 7 Horror Romances That Will Haunt You.

Book Lists that feature Order of the Unseen

FAQs

Who wrote the series?

Molly Doyle.

Molly Doyle has been writing since she was in grade school, and has been a published author since she was sixteen. Once she moved her talents to an online platform, her writing took off. She has reached millions of readers across the globe, with many of them crediting her for their mask kink. When she’s not fantasizing about masked men, she’s plotting her next erotic story.

Source: goodreads.com

How many books in the series?

There are three books in the Order of the Unseen series. The fourth book, Bloodbath, is waiting for a release date.

Where can I find the series?

Get your copy of Scream for Us.

Get your copy of Bloodshed.

Get your copy of Melt for Us.

7 Recs like Order of the Unseen

Dead Devil’s Night by Maree Rose

Dead Devil’s Night by Maree Rose is for readers who enjoy:

Friends-to-Lovers
MFM
Quick Reads
Revenge
Why Choose

Book Description

ONE NIGHT.

That was all it took for Rylan’s world to disappear.

A year has passed, filled with plotting.

Because this year, on that one night, she will make them pay.

THIS DEAD DEVIL’S NIGHT, SHE WILL GIVE THEM THEIR OWN INTRODUCTION TO HELL.

Better Run by Alina May

Better Run by Alina May is for readers who enjoy:

BDSM
MFM
Primal Play
Stalkers
Thrillers

Book Description

Jayden

She’s become my obsession. I hate her for it. I took her for another reason. But now? Now I don’t think I’ll let her go.

Cole

Jayden brought us home a pretty, murderous little plaything. I think I’m going to keep it.

Mary Jo

I’m kidnapped by two twisted, dangerous, and hungry men. I don’t know any of the rules to this fucked up game I’m forced to play. Well, I know I’m not allowed to run. I’ve never been good at following rules. They play with my body and mind, forcing me to join in. Forcing me to like it. But things become increasingly dangerous as I find out the real reason they took me. And it becomes more and more apparent what I need to do to keep both my body and my heart safe…run.

No Way Out by Santana Knox

No Way Out by Santana Knox is for readers who enjoy:

Age Gaps
Dub Con
Masked Men
Quick Reads
Thrillers

Book Description

THERE’S NO WAY OUT OF THE MAZE.

There’s no way out of the maze, there is no way out of the maze. No way out of the maze. No way out.

None.

A teacher.

A student.

A scarecrow.

One dangerously lusty Halloween night in a small Ohio town that will never be forgotten.

No Place to Hide by Harper Ashley and Wren Hawthorne

No Place to Hide by Harper Ashley and Wren Hawthorne is for readers who enjoy:

BDSM
Degradation
Halloween Romance
Quick Reads
Primal Play

Book Description

Blair

All I wanted was one night .

A simple night of fun with my friends at the carnival.

I didn’t know I’d spend it learning things I never knew about myself.

Every twist and turn of our game brings us deeper into our desires.

But what’s a little pain if it’s mixed with unimaginable pleasure?

Jackson

All I wanted was one night .

A simple night of peace doing my job.

I didn’t know I’d spend it pushing the boundaries with a girl I just met.

The stakes get higher the longer the game goes on.

For the first time in my life, will only one night be enough?

Ghost by Kat Blackthorne

The Halloween Boys, Book One

Ghost by Kat Blackthorne is for readers who enjoy:

Age Gaps
Fated Mates
Halloween Romance
Paranormal
Why Choose

Book Description

Ash Grove is a fine place to die.

Blythe has accepted her fate and is tired of running. Who would miss her anyway? She attends her new and eccentric town’s month long Halloween masquerade for one last party before meeting her end. But what will she find…and what will find her?

A man in a skeleton mask is watching… and he’s not the only one.

She’s being hunted by a devil she knows and a ghost she doesn’t. But all is not what it seems in Ash Grove. Not all masks are made of paint and leather. Some are made of flesh and smiles. What’s lurking behind the ordinary facade in this space that swings between Mayberry and Gotham?

Ghost has killed before, he’ll kill again, and his sights are set on Blythe.

The grown up ghost story for anyone who loves Halloween and is ready to meet their new favorite monster.

Tricks and treats lurk around every jack o’lantern and gravestone in this grown up Halloween themed paranormal romance. Meet witches, vampires, wolves, and ghouls, and maybe a few odd birds and pirates too. Sink your teeth into this paranormal urban fantasy romance and get ready for all the Halloween vibes. Come to Ash Grove with an open mind, choose your mask, sit, and stay a spell… if you dare.

Slash or Pass by Tylor Paige

Final Girls, Book One

Slash or Pass by Tylor Paige is for readers who enjoy:

Horror
Knife Play
Masked Men
MFM
Serial Killers

Book Description

When you get told to run, you get up and don’t look back.

We had one shot to get out of the Sinister Minister’s grasp, and we took it. Hand in hand, Kansas and I fled in the middle of the night, with a promise that we’d never tell a soul about what happened at that house, and how Constantine died.

Eisley has spent the last decade looking over her shoulder while trying to forget the horrors The Minister and ‘The Family’ inflicted upon her and others. However, something continues to call to her. In the deepest roots of her psyche, she can’t escape the nightmares of her time trapped in the cult.

All of her fears come to a head when she finds a letter taped to her door, informing her that a documentary is being made about The Minister and the events that took place ten years ago. When she politely declines, she can’t help but wonder why they didn’t fight her more to talk.

It isn’t until she turns on the TV that she sees that they didn’t need her to talk because they had someone else to captivate their audience. They found Constantine.

He’s alive.

He remembers that we left him.

Caution Tape by Molly Doyle and J.D. Midnight

Caution Tape by Molly Doyle and J.D. Midnight is for readers who enjoy:

Bondage
Enemies-to-Lovers
Horror
Impact Play
Serial Killers

Book Description

CORA

It’s exhausting pretending to be normal. Go to therapy. Hold down a job. Smile.

So much smiling.

All I can do is attempt to corral the burning rage that sits in my chest. It’s getting hard.

𝑴𝒚 𝒎𝒂𝒔𝒌 𝒊𝒔 𝒔𝒍𝒊𝒑𝒑𝒊𝒏𝒈…

I’m slowly losing my grip. Reality is getting blurry.

I’m yearning to lash out. To taste blood. For someone to see me for what I truly am.

NOLAN

I’ve kept myself in check. Built the perfect lie. A well-adjusted man with his entire life ahead of him. Allowed myself only daytime fantasies and night drives. It’s not enough.

𝑰’𝒎 𝒕𝒐𝒐 𝒉𝒖𝒏𝒈𝒓𝒚…

Then there’s her. Chipping away at my lie piece by piece. I see her. She has a darkness in her eyes that matches mine.

I want her. I want her wrapped in plastic, squirming and begging me for mercy.

My trophy. My toy. Mine.

And so it begins.

𝐎𝐧𝐞 𝐠𝐚𝐦𝐞.

𝐓𝐰𝐨 𝐦𝐮𝐭𝐮𝐚𝐥 𝐦𝐨𝐧𝐬𝐭𝐞𝐫𝐬.